Goal

  1. Perform Phase estimation for various setup of inputs and outputs, comparing the estimation performance against the Shot Noise limit.
    1. Compare different initial states .
    2. Compare different System/Ancillary couplings ( )
    3. Measure how the uncertainty evolves as the number of trials increases, i.e. estimate the law as .
  2. How does optimizing Fisher Information compare with measuring the sensitivity ?

Potential research plans

Paper URLEvolution modelSummary (incl. open questions)
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-025-09917-9Matter-wave interferometry (massive particles / nanoparticles)Demonstrates interferometry with increasingly massive particles, probing how quantum superposition and sensitivity scale with particle size. A central open question is how coherence and sensitivity scale as mass (effective N) grows, especially under decoherence and environmental coupling. (Nature)
https://journals.aps.org/pra/accepted/10.1103/537s-r3t8Two-channel linear interferometer with squeezed states (Gaussian probes)Shows Heisenberg scaling ( \sim 1/N ) for multiparameter estimation using realistic squeezed light states. Open direction: how to extend Heisenberg scaling robustness to multi-parameter settings under noise and loss, and whether scaling survives realistic imperfections. (journals.aps.org)
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41534-023-00691-ySingle-photon + orbital angular momentum (OAM) interferometryExperimental demonstration of sub-shot-noise scaling across a wide range of N (~30k). Open issue: achieving stable Heisenberg scaling across arbitrarily large N without requiring prior information or adaptive strategies. (Nature)
https://www.mdpi.com/2073-8994/15/3/774General SU(2), SU(1,1), and hybrid interferometers (QCRB framework)Systematic comparison of scaling laws (shot-noise (1/\sqrt{N}), squeezed improvements, etc.). Open questions concern optimal configurations under realistic constraints (loss, asymmetry, correlations) and whether hybrid schemes can systematically reduce the prefactor/exponent. (MDPI)
https://www.mdpi.com/2304-6732/10/7/749Nonlinear interferometers with optical parametric amplifiers (OPA)Studies nonlinear gain-enhanced interferometry approaching Heisenberg scaling. Open problems include trade-offs between gain, losses, and scaling exponent, and whether nonlinear resources can consistently outperform linear schemes in realistic regimes. (MDPI)
https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.08449Heralded large photon-number entangled statesUses finite-size entangled photon states (up to (N=8)) to explore scaling. Open question: how to scale to large N while preserving entanglement-enhanced sensitivity in the presence of loss and imperfect detectors. (arXiv)
https://arxiv.org/abs/1012.5787Interaction-based (nonlinear) quantum metrologyPredicts super-Heisenberg scaling ( \sim N^{-k} ) via k-body interactions. Key open issue: whether such scaling is fundamentally meaningful or survives realistic constraints, since higher-order nonlinearities and noise tend to degrade it. (arXiv)

Alternative plan

  1. Do uncertainty quantification via the Stein Variational Gradient Descent method
    1. Condensed Stein Variational Gradient Descent for Uncertainty Quantification of Neural Networks
    2. https://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.04471

Priorities

  • BS + Phase + BS setup: done in interferometry thesis/ch04-ancilla-vs-system/4-1, 4-4 and ch05-ancilla-optimization/5-1 (BS ); the paper optimises the QFI over all inputs, beam splitters included (§II B).
  • Derivation from the two-mode Hamiltonian to , form: see Jordan-Schwinger representation.
  • Optimal time: without noise , so longer holds always help; with noise the optimum is a window , and under a total time budget the figure of merit is (interferometry papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, §IV B).
  • Particles vs trials: , and for product inputs , so particles are worth exactly repetitions; only entanglement breaks this, and noise largely removes that advantage (interferometry papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, §III). Count-based readouts: §IV F and App. C.
  • Coefficient: without noise, no (). Under noise reaches 1.91 per hold (amplitude damping, ), but uncoupled local fields reach 1.89; the interaction itself contributes at most (interferometry papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, §IV C, ).
  • Power law: no. The noiseless bound holds for any controls, and both Markovian channels violate the HNLS condition, so even full error correction gains only a constant factor (interferometry papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, §V; numerics are , the claim rests on the bounds).
  • Superseded: the paper compares QFI ratios at equal instead of fitting , which means little at (interferometry papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, §III).

Academic Sources

  1. Ring lattices
    1. Ring lattices currents (Bose-Hubbard model) with attractive interactions but can be useful https://scipost.org/10.21468/SciPostPhys.12.4.138
    2. One of the 1st experiments on currents on ring currents (GPE and other models)
    3. This and this is what happens to currents states when we put a barrier in the system. For completeness (but no need to go deep on these)
    4. A barrier in a ring lattice avoids crossing in the 1st part, using superposition of current states. A similar phenomenon is seen in Minguzzi’s paper above.
  2. AQUIDs
    1. 1st experiments by Boshier
    2. Experiment where they measure rotation, by Boshier
    3. Paper on AQUID (atomtronics SQUID) theory
    4. Measurements and observables of currents in ring lattices (with a barrier AQUID like)
    5. AQUID with attractive interactions
  3. Machine Learning
    1. Reinforcement-learning-based matter-wave interferometer in a shaken optical lattice, by Luigi Amico
    2. Rings directly in experimental data: , based on this paper.
  4. Bayesian statistics
    1. Quantum theory of phase estimation, by Luca Pezze.
    2. Dirichlet distribution: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirichlet_distribution
  5. Others
    1. Optimal generators for Quantum Sensing
    2. Phase estimation by pytket

Methodology

  1. Describe a process through where
    1. is the system’s Hamiltonian
    2. is the ancillary’s Hamiltonian
    3. represents the system interactions
    4. is the initial Quantum state.
      1. Try with a Noon state.
  2. Solve
  3. Get by taking the Partial Trace over the ancillary system.
  4. Determine the Measurement probabilities of by calculating .
  5. Maximize sensitivity by
    1. Option A) finding the , where is any of our coefficients .
    2. Option B) Using Bayesian statistics to build the posterior likelihood of , and optimize for lower values of . The prior can be nicely modeled as the Dirichlet Distribution, which is a generalization of the Beta Distribution.
  • Superseded: the paper uses exact Lindblad evolution with Strang splitting (App. D); TEBD suits 1D chains, not all-to-all collective coupling.

Plots

Informational Gain as a function of and .

Higher resolution informational gain

Higher Resolution Probability Difference System

Higher Resolution Probability Difference Ancilla

High resolution information gain for the Mach Zehnder Interferometer

Growth without ancillary

Growth with ancillary

Feedback

  1. Determine the best sensitivity for when the ancillary system is not coupled
  2. Plot as a function of . If it increases by more than a factor of 2 then it will be a sign of quantum interference improving beyond the shot noise limit.
  3. NEXT STEPS:
    1. Learn the Hamiltonian from data based on both observations and time
    2. Build a plot of estimated delta against true delta, as a function of the number of observations
    3. Read the Holland paper https://journals.aps.org/prresearch/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.3.033279

Constraints

  • The ancilla must be bigger than the system’s
  • The ancilla must be bigger than the system’s
  • The ancillary cannot be better than the system while isolated, i.e. cannot provide better measurements than .

Appendix

Assumptions

  1. : we work in dimensionless units
  2. : formal evolution of the system
  3. described the Reduced system
  4. , where
    1. only interacts with
    2. only interacts with
    3. represents the interactions
  5. is our initial state
  6. , where
    1. are the respective Pauli Matrixes.
  7. , where , and is the component of the collective spin in , half the population imbalance between the two modes (see Jordan-Schwinger representation).

On each system, we will often work with the “generic” Hamiltonian (derived in Jordan-Schwinger representation), where

  • is the tunneling strength
  • is the particle interaction
  • is the energy shift

Calculating

Since the left and right operators are conjugates, I use frequently to mean “use the complex conjugate operator as on the left side of “

We care about

We see that the constants and are inconsequential.

Log likelihoods

Given two Dirichlet Distributions, a true distributions with vector and a “wrong” estimated distribution , the log likelihood of the observations, with observations, is given by

This allows us to make use of the loggamma function in calculations, improving numerical stability: https://docs.scipy.org/doc/scipy/reference/generated/scipy.special.loggamma.html.

MetricaNewsletter ExternaNewsletter MembrosWhatsApp
Interacoes80365-10
Leitores987175??
Subscritores3153337422

Next steps

  • Scaling: only without noise; under Markovian noise the per-particle QFI saturates, so with a better constant (interferometry papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, §III).
  • Pre-factor: parallel-strategy ceiling under dephasing is per particle at and at (interferometry papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, §III).
  • Superseded: the ancilla scheme is compared against an MZI with all particles (interferometry papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, Eq. ratio).
  • Superseded: and replace this metric (interferometry papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, Eqs. ratio, ratios).