Goal
- Perform Phase estimation for various setup of inputs and outputs, comparing the estimation performance against the Shot Noise limit.
- Compare different initial states .
- Compare different System/Ancillary couplings ( )
- Measure how the uncertainty evolves as the number of trials increases, i.e. estimate the law as .
- How does optimizing Fisher Information compare with measuring the sensitivity ?
Potential research plans
| Paper URL | Evolution model | Summary (incl. open questions) |
|---|---|---|
| https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-025-09917-9 | Matter-wave interferometry (massive particles / nanoparticles) | Demonstrates interferometry with increasingly massive particles, probing how quantum superposition and sensitivity scale with particle size. A central open question is how coherence and sensitivity scale as mass (effective N) grows, especially under decoherence and environmental coupling. (Nature) |
| https://journals.aps.org/pra/accepted/10.1103/537s-r3t8 | Two-channel linear interferometer with squeezed states (Gaussian probes) | Shows Heisenberg scaling ( \sim 1/N ) for multiparameter estimation using realistic squeezed light states. Open direction: how to extend Heisenberg scaling robustness to multi-parameter settings under noise and loss, and whether scaling survives realistic imperfections. (journals.aps.org) |
| https://www.nature.com/articles/s41534-023-00691-y | Single-photon + orbital angular momentum (OAM) interferometry | Experimental demonstration of sub-shot-noise scaling across a wide range of N (~30k). Open issue: achieving stable Heisenberg scaling across arbitrarily large N without requiring prior information or adaptive strategies. (Nature) |
| https://www.mdpi.com/2073-8994/15/3/774 | General SU(2), SU(1,1), and hybrid interferometers (QCRB framework) | Systematic comparison of scaling laws (shot-noise (1/\sqrt{N}), squeezed improvements, etc.). Open questions concern optimal configurations under realistic constraints (loss, asymmetry, correlations) and whether hybrid schemes can systematically reduce the prefactor/exponent. (MDPI) |
| https://www.mdpi.com/2304-6732/10/7/749 | Nonlinear interferometers with optical parametric amplifiers (OPA) | Studies nonlinear gain-enhanced interferometry approaching Heisenberg scaling. Open problems include trade-offs between gain, losses, and scaling exponent, and whether nonlinear resources can consistently outperform linear schemes in realistic regimes. (MDPI) |
| https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.08449 | Heralded large photon-number entangled states | Uses finite-size entangled photon states (up to (N=8)) to explore scaling. Open question: how to scale to large N while preserving entanglement-enhanced sensitivity in the presence of loss and imperfect detectors. (arXiv) |
| https://arxiv.org/abs/1012.5787 | Interaction-based (nonlinear) quantum metrology | Predicts super-Heisenberg scaling ( \sim N^{-k} ) via k-body interactions. Key open issue: whether such scaling is fundamentally meaningful or survives realistic constraints, since higher-order nonlinearities and noise tend to degrade it. (arXiv) |
Alternative plan
- Do uncertainty quantification via the Stein Variational Gradient Descent method
Priorities
- BS + Phase + BS setup: done in interferometry
thesis/ch04-ancilla-vs-system/4-1,4-4andch05-ancilla-optimization/5-1(BS ); the paper optimises the QFI over all inputs, beam splitters included (§II B). - Derivation from the two-mode Hamiltonian to , form: see Jordan-Schwinger representation.
- Optimal time: without noise , so longer holds always help; with noise the optimum is a window , and under a total time budget the figure of merit is (interferometry
papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, §IV B). - Particles vs trials: , and for product inputs , so particles are worth exactly repetitions; only entanglement breaks this, and noise largely removes that advantage (interferometry
papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, §III). Count-based readouts: §IV F and App. C. - Coefficient: without noise, no (). Under noise reaches 1.91 per hold (amplitude damping, ), but uncoupled local fields reach 1.89; the interaction itself contributes at most (interferometry
papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, §IV C, ). - Power law: no. The noiseless bound holds for any controls, and both Markovian channels violate the HNLS condition, so even full error correction gains only a constant factor (interferometry
papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, §V; numerics are , the claim rests on the bounds). - Superseded: the paper compares QFI ratios at equal instead of fitting , which means little at (interferometry
papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, §III).
Academic Sources
- Ring lattices
- Ring lattices currents (Bose-Hubbard model) with attractive interactions but can be useful https://scipost.org/10.21468/SciPostPhys.12.4.138
- One of the 1st experiments on currents on ring currents (GPE and other models)
- This and this is what happens to currents states when we put a barrier in the system. For completeness (but no need to go deep on these)
- A barrier in a ring lattice avoids crossing in the 1st part, using superposition of current states. A similar phenomenon is seen in Minguzzi’s paper above.
- AQUIDs
- Machine Learning
- Bayesian statistics
- Quantum theory of phase estimation, by Luca Pezze.
- Dirichlet distribution: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirichlet_distribution
- Others
Methodology
- Describe a process through where
- is the system’s Hamiltonian
- is the ancillary’s Hamiltonian
- represents the system interactions
- is the initial Quantum state.
- Try with a Noon state.
- Solve
- Get by taking the Partial Trace over the ancillary system.
- Determine the Measurement probabilities of by calculating .
- Maximize sensitivity by
- Option A) finding the , where is any of our coefficients .
- Option B) Using Bayesian statistics to build the posterior likelihood of , and optimize for lower values of . The prior can be nicely modeled as the Dirichlet Distribution, which is a generalization of the Beta Distribution.
- Superseded: the paper uses exact Lindblad evolution with Strang splitting (App. D); TEBD suits 1D chains, not all-to-all collective coupling.
Plots
Informational Gain as a function of and .

Higher resolution informational gain

Higher Resolution Probability Difference System

Higher Resolution Probability Difference Ancilla

High resolution information gain for the Mach Zehnder Interferometer

Growth without ancillary


Growth with ancillary


Feedback
- Determine the best sensitivity for when the ancillary system is not coupled
- Plot as a function of . If it increases by more than a factor of 2 then it will be a sign of quantum interference improving beyond the shot noise limit.
- NEXT STEPS:
- Learn the Hamiltonian from data based on both observations and time
- Build a plot of estimated delta against true delta, as a function of the number of observations
- Read the Holland paper https://journals.aps.org/prresearch/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.3.033279
Constraints
- The ancilla must be bigger than the system’s
- The ancilla must be bigger than the system’s
- The ancillary cannot be better than the system while isolated, i.e. cannot provide better measurements than .
Appendix
Assumptions
- : we work in dimensionless units
- : formal evolution of the system
- described the Reduced system
- , where
- only interacts with
- only interacts with
- represents the interactions
- is our initial state
- , where
- are the respective Pauli Matrixes.
- , where , and is the component of the collective spin in , half the population imbalance between the two modes (see Jordan-Schwinger representation).
On each system, we will often work with the “generic” Hamiltonian (derived in Jordan-Schwinger representation), where
- is the tunneling strength
- is the particle interaction
- is the energy shift
Calculating
Since the left and right operators are conjugates, I use frequently to mean “use the complex conjugate operator as on the left side of “
We care about
We see that the constants and are inconsequential.
Log likelihoods
Given two Dirichlet Distributions, a true distributions with vector and a “wrong” estimated distribution , the log likelihood of the observations, with observations, is given by
This allows us to make use of the loggamma function in calculations, improving numerical stability: https://docs.scipy.org/doc/scipy/reference/generated/scipy.special.loggamma.html.
| Metrica | Newsletter Externa | Newsletter Membros | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Interacoes | 80 | 36 | 5-10 |
| Leitores | 987 | 175 | ?? |
| Subscritores | 3153 | 337 | 422 |
Next steps
- Scaling: only without noise; under Markovian noise the per-particle QFI saturates, so with a better constant (interferometry
papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, §III). - Pre-factor: parallel-strategy ceiling under dephasing is per particle at and at (interferometry
papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, §III). - Superseded: the ancilla scheme is compared against an MZI with all particles (interferometry
papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, Eq.ratio). - Superseded: and replace this metric (interferometry
papers/ancilla-noisy-mzi/main.tex, Eqs.ratio,ratios).